Known Donor Agreements: Roles and Questions for Counsel
A known-donor arrangement begins with an intended donation role. A co-parenting arrangement begins with an intended parenting role. Those descriptions help organize conversations, but they do not determine legal status. Requirements depend on jurisdiction, the people involved, and the treatment route.
Define the role before choosing document wording
Discuss whether you want donation, contact with the child, an ongoing relationship with the family, shared care, or shared decision-making. If the answers differ, write down the difference. Do not assume that the label “donor” makes every expectation compatible.
ASRM’s donation ethics opinion addresses information and expectations in donor conception. Ethical guidance is useful background; it does not establish a donor’s rights or duties under state law.
Topics to take to an attorney
| Topic | Preparation question |
|---|---|
| Parentage | What establishes or excludes legal parentage in our circumstances? |
| Support and rights | How do applicable laws affect possible responsibilities and rights? What can a private agreement actually do? |
| Contact | What contact do we intend, how would it change, and what implications should we understand? |
| Information | How will medical updates, identity information, and communication be handled? |
| Treatment route | Are clinic involvement, consents, screening, or other steps required? |
| Changes | What happens if expectations change or a disagreement arises? |
Privacy and future information
Agree on how sensitive records are shared and stored. Ask the clinic what information is needed, who receives it, and how updates should be communicated. Identity expectations also deserve a careful discussion: do not promise lifelong anonymity without considering genetic testing and other ways people may discover relatives.
Ask professionals which records should be retained, who holds them, and how the child’s future questions can be addressed. Disclosure is a continuing family conversation, not just a box on a form.
An involved donor is a question, not a verdict
Hypothetical example: a prospective donor expects birthday visits, while the recipient expects occasional medical updates only. They should record that difference and ask counsel about the intended contact and its implications. This example does not determine parentage from visits, payments, or the name a child uses.
Review intended contact, documents, and legal questions together with qualified counsel.
Prepare for clinical and legal consultations
- Bring a summary of intended roles, contact expectations, and jurisdictions.
- Ask the clinic about screening, consent, sperm handling, storage, and release policies.
- Ask counsel which documents and steps should be completed before treatment.
- Request a written fee quote that separates drafting, review, revisions, and any later steps.
Use the AAAA directory to begin a professional search and verify suitability independently. The toolkit contains discussion materials, not a completed donor agreement or a determination of donor status.
Free seven-day preparation course
One short email a day covering roles, costs, consultations, agreements, and conversation topics. Confirm your email address to start.
Continue reading: Comparing intended roles · Agreement consultations · Conversation questions